my judging:
PPSC Tournament 2010 Round 4 Results as of Nov. 27, 2010.
Senxa for the late judging. As you can see, wala ako dito for the
past weeks kasi busy ako sa school. Ngayon, gumagawa pa ako
project, pero ayan, judge muna ako para matapos na ang
paghintay. Senxa talaga guys :/
xperryment vs {TH}Enzo
xperryment:
Execution: 4
Difficulty: 4
Creativity: 4
Presentation: 5
Total: 17
A very excellent combo coming from you!
Work on your left hand especially sa intro. There were times na
nawala ang either smoothness or momentum mo. sa TF
Charge[PD]. Also, at 0:40. Sa 0:28, try mo to make the combo
continue at the same direction, suggest lang :P pero overall,
excellent. Nice use of finger flexibility in the middle part.
Also, I
would advise you to expand pa ang linkages mo. Some of them
are repetitive from the other rounds/ too much at times. ^^
{TH}Enzo:
Execution: 4
Difficulty: 4
Creativity:4
Presentation: 5
Total: 17
Excellent as well. Many will not notice the
subtle difficulty from the linkages. The "deformity" of your hand
has its advantages in making the combo appealing, but also a
little bit choppy at some places (0:12). I like how you did not rely
that much on powertricks, but on difficult linkages. ^^
Winner: Tie (Honestly, both spinners deserve a place in
the Elite 8 because each has their own strengths as well as
weaknesses, kaya nahirapan ako magbigay ng points ^^)
{TH}Ar vs Excrisvirus
{TH}Ar
Execution: 4
Difficulty: 4
Creativity: 3
Presentation:4
Total: 15
The way kung paano mo inexecute ang
tricks mo, it seems na parang hindi naging smooth ang kalabasan.
:/ Anu yun sa 0:10? XD also, 0:11-0:13, ok yun pag magagawa mo
smoothly at/or mabilis. Pero sa pagtingin ko sa vid, hindi
maganda ang kinalabasan na speed. :/ Improve sa style. Try to
make your combo a little bit more smooth. Or
maybe...aesthetically appealing
Excrisvirus
Execution: 4
Difficulty: 5
Creativity: 3
Presentation: 3
Total: 15
First of all, sa isang untrained eye (*cough*),
hindi maapreciate ang combo, kapag ang cam mismo ay hindi
maganda quality. Ok naman, nakikita ko most of the combo, pero
pag icoconsider mo, may mga parts gaya ng 0:04-0:05 na malilito
ang iba sa ginawa mo, kasi hindi makikita ang fingers, for
examples. Malay mo, baka may ginawa kang finger flexibility doon
at di ko napansin kasi blurry maxado ang cam. Also, 0:10-0:11.
Advise ko rin sa iyo na (base sa paglalakbay ko sa UPSB), marami
di maxado aprub (esp. mga oldies gaya ni i.suk) pag excessive
powertricks. Just saying^^. I like the 1p2h transfers
Winner: Tie (again?!)
PSVorteX vs Sound
PSVorteX
Execution: 4
Difficulty: 4
Creativity: 3
Presentation: 4
Total: 15
Gumagaling ka na.
I applaud you sa
paggaling mo, pero I would suggest really more links. (See
explanation on EV's comments sa power). Not saying na bad yun,
pero if excessive yun, you might get lower points for creativity. I
see some nice linkages there. ^^ Clean up 0:16, also, 0:23
Sound
Execution: 4
Difficulty: 4
Creativity: 4
Presentation: 4
Total: 16
Too many offcams D: I see some Sonic 24s there.
I like rin
how linkages ang weapon mo dito.
honestly, di ko maxado
magrade nang maayos, dahil sa offcams mo. Also, don't be afraid
to mix some power. remember, power is not limited to hai tuas,
peem stuff,etc. cont Pinkybaks, swivels, etc can be considered as
power. at 0:06, nawala ang "rhythm" mo for a split second.
Winner: Sound
{TH}Matthew vs {TH}Gerard
{TH}Matthew
Execution:
Difficulty:
Creativity:
Presentation:
Total:
{TH}Gerard
Execution: 3
Difficulty: 4
Creativity: 3
Presentation: 4
Total: 14
I'm predicting minadalian mo yung paggawa
ng combo? not much content, except for some parts. Also,
0:04-0:05, 0:07. yung outro, parang di tugma ang linkages, parang
nagcocontradict siya. basta wag mu lang pagmadalian ang
paggawa ^^
Winner:
{TH}Eduard vs Deathfish vs GAME vs {TH}Jimuel
{TH}Eduard:
Execution: 4
Difficulty: 4
Creativity: 4
Presentation: 3
Total: 15
Weird intro? Perhaps siguro sa angle. It
seems na yung aim mo rin is jerky hand + linkages? moar content
please.
and the angle, parang di compatible sa combo. :/
Deathfish:
Execution: 5
Difficulty: 4
Creativity: 4
Presentation: 5
Total: 18
I gotta say, a well-executed combo, though
the outro was kinda "shocking" in terms of speed. Nothing much
to comment, since it is an excellent combo. the transition
between directions was unnoticeable
. Perhaps another kind
of ending? :P
GAME:
Execution: 5
Difficulty: 4
Creativity: 3
Presentation: 4
Total: 16
Well, I gotta be frank, this is a peem style vid,
in a negative way, that is :/ disregarding the intro and the baks
part, makikita mo lahat yun sa previous combos ni peem nung
'09. :/ also, try to get some lighting. Ok naman kahit wala, pero
dark ang video. :/ Well, na-explain mo rin ang reason sa
description, so yeah. Wag lng irush next time ^^. I gotta love the
execution, though
{TH}Jimuel:
Execution:
Difficulty:
Creativity:
Presentation:
Total:
Winner(s):
Mu3ic vs Javascript vs ultimatespinnerasb
Mu3ic:
Execution: 4
Difficulty: 4
Creativity: 3
Presentation: 4
Total: 15
Same intro sa PSVorteX's vid in R3, i think?
Well, for the most part, much of the combo was average in
linkages. I saw FL TA rev used at least 4-5 times. :/ The outro was
kinda okay.
Also, mods look very big in your hands :O
Javascript:
Execution: 4
Difficulty: 4
Creativity: 4
Presentation: 2
Total: 14
Vid was too dark. :/ I saw you used
ScriptSpin for the intro. And...not counting the scriptspin, bak
portion and the power trick outro, the combo was made up of
spam :/ Pang kuha ng momentum :/ next time, try some more
linkages
ultimatespinnerasb:
Execution: 4
Difficulty: 3
Creativity: 3
Presentation: 4
Total: 14
Most of your combo was made up of the "bonkura bakfall
harmonic" followed by some average linkages. I suggest that you
create combos that have some more...."spice" to it. Very
average. try to zoom out your camera for spinning room. :/
Winner: Mu3ic
)
